3.31.2020

What More Than Bread Constitutes Our Lives?

Matthew Croasmun

,

This article first appeared at gracefarms.org.
Bread, hands kneading bread
3.31.2020

What More Than Bread Constitutes Our Lives?

Matthew Croasmun

Heading
3.31.2020

What More Than Bread Constitutes Our Lives?

Matthew Croasmun

,

Heading
3.31.2020

What More Than Bread Constitutes Our Lives?

Matthew Croasmun

,

Heading
Copy link

episode notes

This article first appeared at gracefarms.org.

The COVID-19 pandemic has raised a number of urgent questions. The most recent, grabbing newspaper headlines, asks what sort of tradeoff we should be making between our health and our economic well-being. When does the cure become worse than the disease?

The Hebrew scriptures millennia ago offered an insight that has proven timeless: “The human does not live by bread alone” (Deuteronomy 8:3). This is not to say that humans can live without bread. Rather, it’s to insist that our lives consist of more than bread—more than the material things of life.

As Miroslav Volf has argued in his book Flourishing: Why We Need Religion in a Globalized World, all of the world’s great religious traditions, in one form or another, affirm this insight. Jesus is said to have quoted it verbatim when tempted by Satan to use divine power to relieve his own hunger. Confucius counsels: “Virtue is more essential to the people than water and fire” (Analects 15:35). And the Buddha once described the material abundance of his father’s palace as a “burning house” from which he needed to escape.

In light of this ancient wisdom, the argument about medical versus economic well-being is really an argument about which type of bread, provided for which people, is more essential. This is almost certainly a false choice; prosperity will slip through our fingers if we don’t attend to our health and, in our interconnected world, a healthy body is impossible in the context of economic collapse. That’s just the sort of thing our flourishing is; it’s a integrated whole. And that whole is important — including the bread. To say that we do not live by bread alone is not to say that we can or should live without “bread”— without health, without healthcare, N95 masks, respirators, or the rest—but to make the point that human beings need more than material goods to live a flourishing life. This demands we ask ourselves a question:

What more than bread constitutes our lives?

The Hebrew scripture goes on to give an answer: we live by “every word that comes from the mouth of the Lord.” Each of the world’s religious and philosophical traditions proposes an importantly different set of answers rooted, alternatively: in insight into the nature of reality, in peace with God and God’s creation, in submission to God, in the happiness of all without preference for oneself, in the safely secured virtue of the sage, in the Way.

In the midst of a pandemic, this question is present in new and pressing ways. We can update it for this moment: What more than bodily health and economic security constitutes our lives? What more than toilet paper, Clorox wipes, milk, and Netflix queues makes our lives worthy of our humanity?

This crisis can be a revelatory moment of rupture for us if we have ears to hear.

What is this more in our lives? Is it art? Is it nature? Is it community? Is it something about the interconnectedness of our flourishing—that my well-being depends on your actions and your well-being on mine? Is it justice? Is it something about the fact that, even as we see the depth of our interconnectedness, we also see plainly the different costs each is asked to pay: white collar workers who more and less seamlessly shift their work to home; medical workers and first responders putting themselves in harm’s way; blue collar workers laid off or continuing to work at risk to themselves and their loved ones; “gig economy” workers making “shelter-in-place” possible by shuttling groceries and medications (and their latest Amazon whims) to others’ doorsteps? Is it faith?

What more constitutes our lives? Even as we do our very best (as we must!) to secure the bread our world needs—the health and well-being of our neighbors—we are confronted with an opportunity, a responsibility to ask ourselves this ancient question anew.

What sort of tradeoff should we make between our health and our economic well-being? When does the cure become worse than the disease?

The COVID-19 pandemic has raised a number of urgent questions. The most recent, grabbing newspaper headlines, asks what sort of tradeoff we should be making between our health and our economic well-being. When does the cure become worse than the disease?

The Hebrew scriptures millennia ago offered an insight that has proven timeless: “The human does not live by bread alone” (Deuteronomy 8:3). This is not to say that humans can live without bread. Rather, it’s to insist that our lives consist of more than bread—more than the material things of life.

As Miroslav Volf has argued in his book Flourishing: Why We Need Religion in a Globalized World, all of the world’s great religious traditions, in one form or another, affirm this insight. Jesus is said to have quoted it verbatim when tempted by Satan to use divine power to relieve his own hunger. Confucius counsels: “Virtue is more essential to the people than water and fire” (Analects 15:35). And the Buddha once described the material abundance of his father’s palace as a “burning house” from which he needed to escape.

In light of this ancient wisdom, the argument about medical versus economic well-being is really an argument about which type of bread, provided for which people, is more essential. This is almost certainly a false choice; prosperity will slip through our fingers if we don’t attend to our health and, in our interconnected world, a healthy body is impossible in the context of economic collapse. That’s just the sort of thing our flourishing is; it’s a integrated whole. And that whole is important — including the bread. To say that we do not live by bread alone is not to say that we can or should live without “bread”— without health, without healthcare, N95 masks, respirators, or the rest—but to make the point that human beings need more than material goods to live a flourishing life. This demands we ask ourselves a question:

What more than bread constitutes our lives?

The Hebrew scripture goes on to give an answer: we live by “every word that comes from the mouth of the Lord.” Each of the world’s religious and philosophical traditions proposes an importantly different set of answers rooted, alternatively: in insight into the nature of reality, in peace with God and God’s creation, in submission to God, in the happiness of all without preference for oneself, in the safely secured virtue of the sage, in the Way.

In the midst of a pandemic, this question is present in new and pressing ways. We can update it for this moment: What more than bodily health and economic security constitutes our lives? What more than toilet paper, Clorox wipes, milk, and Netflix queues makes our lives worthy of our humanity?

This crisis can be a revelatory moment of rupture for us if we have ears to hear.

What is this more in our lives? Is it art? Is it nature? Is it community? Is it something about the interconnectedness of our flourishing—that my well-being depends on your actions and your well-being on mine? Is it justice? Is it something about the fact that, even as we see the depth of our interconnectedness, we also see plainly the different costs each is asked to pay: white collar workers who more and less seamlessly shift their work to home; medical workers and first responders putting themselves in harm’s way; blue collar workers laid off or continuing to work at risk to themselves and their loved ones; “gig economy” workers making “shelter-in-place” possible by shuttling groceries and medications (and their latest Amazon whims) to others’ doorsteps? Is it faith?

What more constitutes our lives? Even as we do our very best (as we must!) to secure the bread our world needs—the health and well-being of our neighbors—we are confronted with an opportunity, a responsibility to ask ourselves this ancient question anew.

Matthew Croasmun

Matthew Croasmun

Associate Research Scholar

Matthew Croasmun is Associate Research Scholar and director of the Life Worth Living program at the Yale Center for Faith & Culture and lecturer of Humanities at Yale University.

Heading for a Downloadable Resource

Article

Lies and Dys-order

Ryan McAnnally-Linz

Gathering Joy
Video

Gathering Joy

Willie Jennings

The Future of Theology
Video

The Future of Theology

George Marsden

Life Worth Living and the University
Video

Life Worth Living and the University

Jonathan Holloway

Life Worth Living and the Utilitarian Tradition
Video

Life Worth Living and the Utilitarian Tradition

Julia Wise

Reading Theology as a Scholar and Teacher of Religious Studies
Video

Reading Theology as a Scholar and Teacher of Religious Studies

Tyler Roberts

Virtue and Flourishing
Video

Virtue and Flourishing

Katie Grimes

Theology in Our Pluralistic Moment
Video

Theology in Our Pluralistic Moment

Katherine Sonderegger

A Muslim Vision of the Life Worth Living
Video

A Muslim Vision of the Life Worth Living

Shaykh Hamza Yusuf

2015 Christ and the Good Life Course at Yale Divinity School
Video

2015 Christ and the Good Life Course at Yale Divinity School

Miroslav Volf

Character, Flourishing & the Good Life: A Conversation with David Brooks and Miroslav Volf
Video

Character, Flourishing & the Good Life: A Conversation with David Brooks and Miroslav Volf

David Brooks

David Brooks & Miroslav Volf

Following Jesus as a Secular Progressive?
Video

Following Jesus as a Secular Progressive?

Tom Krattenmaker

Tom Krattenmaker & Tony Kriz

Theology of Joy
Video

Theology of Joy

N.T. Wright

N.T. Wright & Miroslav Volf

The Joy of Humility
Book

The Joy of Humility

Drew Collins

Drew Collins and others

The End of Youth Ministry?
Book

The End of Youth Ministry?

Andrew Root

Andrew Root and others

Exclusion and Embrace
Book

Exclusion and Embrace

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

Always On
Book

Always On

Angela Gorrell

Angela Gorrell and others

For the Life of the World
Book

For the Life of the World

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

The Emergence of Sin
Book

The Emergence of Sin

Matthew Croasmun

Matthew Croasmun and others

Envisioning the Good Life
Book

Envisioning the Good Life

Matthew Croasmun

Matthew Croasmun and others

Flourishing
Book

Flourishing

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

Public Faith in Action
Book

Public Faith in Action

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

Joy and Human Flourishing
Book

Joy and Human Flourishing

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

A Public Faith
Book

A Public Faith

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

Do We Worship The Same God?
Book

Do We Worship The Same God?

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

Allah
Book

Allah

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

Captive to the Word of God
Book

Captive to the Word of God

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

Against the Tide
Book

Against the Tide

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

A Common Word
Book

A Common Word

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

The End of Memory
Book

The End of Memory

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

Free of Charge
Book

Free of Charge

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

The Future of Hope
Book

The Future of Hope

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

Practicing Theology
Book

Practicing Theology

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

Work in the Spirit
Book

Work in the Spirit

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

A Passion for God's Reign
Book

A Passion for God's Reign

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

After Our Likeness
Book

After Our Likeness

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others

The Future of Theology
Book

The Future of Theology

Miroslav Volf

Miroslav Volf and others